One of the locally relevant Census ads that TRT staff helped create created

Apparently, those folks flacking for the U.S. Census just think “teepee” when they think “Indian” and, as a result, their attempts to pull in Native Americans for the 2010 count instead repelled some members of the Hoopa Valley Tribe.

As the Two Rivers Tribune reports in its latest issue, TRT Advertising Clerk Connie J. Davis was shocked when she saw the Census ads that would be running in our region, depicting a Plains Indian with teepees in the background. Said Davis:

My immediate reaction was, ‘there’s no way we can print those!’ … None of the ads they sent us reflected our region.

So Davis complained to G & G Advertising, the Census Bureau subcontractor that made the ad, and G & G sent over a couple more efforts. Wrong and wrong again.

So the TRT took over and made their own dang ads, with help from facilitated by New America Media. They created four regionally relevant ads — including the one up top and the one below — reflecting the importance of rivers and salmon and tribal culture to local people. The ads apparently impressed a congressional Census subcommittee that met earlier this year.

As an odd side note, a post on New America Media’s Web site about this and similar Census outreach efforts has a goofily off detail on the living situations of present-day Hupa people, with regards to the teepee question:

Their community’s “trusted voices” ultimately advised that the [teepee] image was inappropriately stereotypical and irrelevant to the Hupa, who live in subterranean housing, in northeastern Humboldt County’s Redwoods.

 

 

Heidi Walters worked as a staff writer at the North Coast Journal from 2005 to 2015.

Join the Conversation

14 Comments

  1. Certainly a culturally insensitive cover. Like teepees, totem poles were not from this area.

  2. I have not liked the last several covers, either: the barfing trees, etc. and it includes this week. The Journal can do better.

  3. Oh, please. If the exurb of McKinleyville has any cultural symbol at all, it would have to be Ernie Pierson’s kitchy carving. That’s not our fault; it’s McKinleyville’s. That totem pole has no religious significance to anyone at all except Jack Durham.

    We’ve had a top-notch run of covers lately. Thx, graphics people!

  4. i just thought it was odd considering you have a native american candidate’s face on there.

  5. Who decided the placement of the canidate’s faces on the totem pole cover? Is there any significance to the order of the canidate’s face ? just curious

  6. If you turn it upside down and put on prismatic glasses and hold it up to a grow light you can see that is says "Paul is Dead."

  7. Good article, good laugh at the end–about where the Hupa people live. And I agree–the cover is dumb and insensitive . . .

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *