Months after a multi-agency probe began into allegations Miranda’s Rescue took money from individuals, shelters and rescues with promises to give animals a second lease on life but instead euthanized them for profit, the investigation remains ongoing.
In a recently released statement, Humboldt County Sheriff William Honsal emphasized that he understands there’s public frustration but noted it was “an extremely complex case.”
“Investigations of this nature often involve peeling back layers of information. As investigators uncover additional evidence, new questions arise, and additional leads must be pursued,” he said. “We are continuing to determine the full scope of this case, and our investigative team remains committed to working diligently alongside our state and federal partners.”
Other agencies involved include the California Attorney General’s Office, California Department of Justice, United States Department of Agriculture, Federal Bureau of Investigation and Humboldt County District Attorney’s Office.
“Our investigation remains focused on allegations of animal cruelty and fraud. At this time, we are not prepared to discuss specific evidence, investigative findings or potential criminal charges,” Honsal said.
“We want the public to understand that we are taking this investigation very seriously. Our priority is not simply to complete it quickly, but to ensure it is conducted thoroughly, objectively and professionally,” he continued. “Any criminal charges pursued must be supported by credible, admissible evidence that can withstand the legal process and establish guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.”
The case began to unfold in late April, when animal welfare advocates Jennifer Raymond and Jenna Moore snuck onto the sprawling Fortuna property from the home that Raymond had recently bought next door due to her suspicions about the operation.
Under the cover of darkness, the pair dug up eight dogs from the Miranda’s Rescue grounds, taking the evidence to authorities, along with documentation of more than 600 animals transferred to the rescue from shelters in 2025 alone. (Read more in the North Coast Journal’s two-part series “Miranda’s Rescue Under Scrutiny,” published June 18 and June 25.)
Soon after, Humboldt County Sheriff’s Office investigators served a search warrant, seizing records, a phone, iPad, laptop, guns and ammunition.
Then, in June, a coalition of local, state and federal agencies conducted extensive excavations at the site, uncovering the “intact” remains of 117 dogs from two digs sites. Forensic veterinarians placed the preliminary cause of death for many of the 70 dogs examined at the scene as gunshot wounds. Additional bones, including 21 canine skulls, were also found.
Investigators also located an area of a barn where the dogs were believed to have been shot, with evidence including spent shell casings and blood spatter. In the same area, 661 collars were found, some bearing names and dog license numbers.
As the Journal has reported, and Honsal also previously stated, under California law, a rescue can put down an animal with a gun, so long as it is shot in the head for a quick death. Killing for financial gain and not providing promised and paid for services, like caring for an animal, could bring charges of fraud and/or cruelty.
During a July 2 press conference following the excavation, Honsal presented preliminary numbers from the investigation indicating at least 981 dogs were either surrendered at the site or transferred to the rescue by shelters across California between January of 2025 and around the end of April. As of then, 116 had been verified as adopted, another 71 were found at Miranda’s Rescue on May 20.
“That leaves,” he said, “731 dogs unaccounted for.”
Due to compliance issues unrelated to the investigation, the conditional use permit for Miranda’s Rescue is currently suspended. In an email to the Journal, Humboldt County Building and Planning and Building Department Director John Ford said that owner and founder Shannon Miranda is “not allowed to take in dogs or adopt dogs out as part of the rescue” at this time.
In response to a question about how many animals might remain, Ford wrote that he believes “there are 23 dogs on the site.”
On Tuesday, as the Journal was readying to go to press, Lost Coast Outpost reported Miranda, who has repeatedly denied any wrongdoing, has applied for a permit to take down the cattery on site. It is unclear how many cats may remain or where they would be housed in the future.
Miranda had been allowing Animal Control to conduct site visits three days a week, with a vet also checking in, but stopped the voluntary compliance back in September, according to the Outpost.
In an email to the Journal, Honsal said that his office “does not have the legal authority to enter the property. Absent consent from Mr. Miranda, a valid search warrant or exigent circumstances, entering private property to conduct an inspection would be a violation of the Fourth Amendment.”
“As such, we cannot conduct an inspection of the property without an appropriate legal basis for entry.”
The sheriff’s office had previously requested court-ordered monitoring be granted when applying for the search warrant served back in May but that was denied.
Moving forward, Honsal said his office “will continue to share information when it is appropriate to do so” but “we will not sacrifice the integrity of this investigation or any potential future prosecution to satisfy public curiosity.”
“We recognize the significant public interest in this case and understand the community’s desire for answers and accountability. However, we also have a responsibility to protect the integrity of the investigation and any potential future prosecution,” he said. “Those accused of crimes are entitled to a fair trial before an impartial jury. Releasing investigative details or evidence prematurely could jeopardize that right and compromise our ability to successfully prosecute those responsible.”
He noted that the “limited information” being released may be “frustrating to those who have been closely following this case.”
“Our discretion is intentional. Our responsibility is to seek justice based on the evidence, not to try a case in the court of public opinion,” the sheriff continued.
“My direction to our investigative team remains clear: Uncover the truth, hold those responsible accountable when the evidence supports criminal charges, and never compromise the integrity of this investigation for the sake of providing premature updates.”
Kimberly Wear (she/her) is the assistant editor at the Journal. Reach her at (707) 442-1400 ext. 105 or kim@northcoastjournal.com.
This article appears in A 37-Year Promise.
