Just before 8 p.m. County Clerk-Recorder Carolyn Crnich says that around 26,000 absentee and vote-by-mail ballots were sent out for this election. Ten thousand of those have been counted and should be available shortly. There’s 3,000 of these ballots that are in the Elections Office’s possession but uncounted. They will not be counted tonight.

8:01 p.m. First absentees should be in any moment now. Note that there will be a long gap between this first report and the next. Crnich said this evening that she doesn’t expect the first precinct results until about 9:30 p.m. Reminder: Results available from this page.

8:09 p.m. First absentee results ETA 8:15 p.m., says elections….

[Relive election night glory after the jump. Spoiler alert: Jimmy Smith won, Mark Lovelace won, and there’ll be a runoff Second District …]

8:19 p.m.

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FIRST DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 23
Precincts Reporting 0 0.0 %
Total Votes 2471

JOHN M. VEVODA 623 25.21%
JIMMY SMITH 1846 74.71%

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SECOND DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 27
Precincts Reporting 0 0.0 %
Total Votes 3236

CLIF CLENDENEN 1178 36.40%
ROGER RODONI 1270 39.25%
ESTELLE FENNELL 782 24.17%

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS THIRD DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 28
Precincts Reporting 0 0.0 %
Total Votes 1808

BRYAN PLUMLEY 779 43.09%
PAUL PITINO 211 11.67%
MARK LOVELACE 813 44.97%

8:22 p.m.: Whoa! That’s Clendenen and Smith awfully strong out of the gate. In the Third, Lovelace must be feeling just a tad disappointed, but it’s a truism that absentees skew conservative. Except in the Second, apparently.

8:28 p.m. Might as well call it — Jimmy Smith wins in the First District.

8:33 p.m. One caveat about those Second District results — much of Southern Humboldt is vote-by-mail, which means the hippies vote absentee just like the conservatives do. Still, a very, very strong showing for Clendenen. Remember, if Rodoni fails to get 50 percent plus one, that means that it’s a Clendenen-Fennell runoff in November. Rodoni’s numbers, so far, are way beneath that. The first precinct results will tell the tale — those will almost certainly be your Fortuna voters.

8:41 p.m.: Vevoda on KHUM: “It was very, very challenging, to say the least.” Then: “I learned that there are some very, very mean individuals out there.” He says that someone took the lug nuts off of a truck that was pulling a Vevoda sign. He blames it on politics, and said a police report has been filed. “It’s just lucky no one was killed.”

8:45 p.m.: Heidi Walters at the Clendenen party. She says there’s about 30 people there for the party — more just hanging out at the bar. Apparently no one there knows that their candidate is pulling off a victory.

8:51 p.m.: Johanna Rodoni is about to give a speech in the Hot Brew, according to Japhet Weeks. Earlier, she told him that she thought the results were looking good for Rodoni. “The fact that Roger is ahead in the absentees is a good sign,” she said. O RLY?

9:00 p.m. “It’s been a difficult campaign for all of us,” Johanna Rodoni tells a group of about 100 at Hot Brew. “I feel blessed to have you all here. However we come out on this, we’re all winners.” In the crowd: Fortuna Mayor John Campbell, Sheriff Gary Philp and the mayors of Fortuna and Rio Dell.

9:04 p.m.: First two precincts of the night returned to elections — Ridgewood School and the Humboldt County Office of Education.

9:05 p.m.: Supervisor Jimmy Smith is spending the evening at the Elections Office. He tells Meghannraye Sutton that he doesn’t want to jump to any conclusions. “”It’s been a difficult campaign for all of us,” he says. “I feel blessed to have you all here. However we come out on this, we’re all winners.” “”Looking at this list of candidates — I know all of them, and I’ve talked to all of them, and I know they’re working their hearts out right now,” he says.

9:10 p.m.: Roger and Johanna’s daughter Monica tells Japhet Weeks that when this election started getting close, her parents had a discussion about which of them would run this time around. They eventually settled on Roger, figuring it would be his last time before handing it off to her. So, she said, when her father was killed it wasn’t that much of a stretch for her mother to step into his shoes.

9:31 p.m.: “We’ve dealt with a campaign that threw a lot of money into electing a legacy,” Estelle Fennell tells Japhet Weeks. She says that her campaign was expecting Rodoni to get a big bump from the absentees, and that didn’t happen. She says that she’s looking forward to a November runoff with Clendenen.

9:37 p.m.: Food at Fennell HQ: two types of baguette sandwich (pesto and cranberry, goat cheese and olive), veggie wraps, falafel, Santa Cruz juices, wine. Food at Rodoni HQ: Swedish meatballs, bean dip and chips, off-the-shelf juices and hard liquor.

9:45 p.m.:

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FIRST DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 23
Precincts Reporting 9 39.1 %
Total Votes 3448

JOHN M. VEVODA 894 25.93%
JIMMY SMITH 2551 73.98%
Write-in Votes 3 0.09%

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SECOND DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 27
Precincts Reporting 0 0.0 %
Total Votes 3236

CLIF CLENDENEN 1178 36.40%
ROGER RODONI 1270 39.25%
ESTELLE FENNELL 782 24.17%
Write-in Votes 6 0.19%

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS THIRD DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 28
Precincts Reporting 1 3.6 %
Total Votes 1905

BRYAN PLUMLEY 798 41.89%
PAUL PITINO 223 11.71%
MARK LOVELACE 878 46.09%
Write-in Votes 6 0.31%

9:47 p.m.: Ten precincts in out of 105, none of them from the Second District. In the Third, Plumley drops a bit, Lovelace gains a bit.

9:59 p.m.: Larry from KHUM — hey, Larry! — updates us on the food situation. At Plumley HQ: Wings and cheese fries. At Lovelace HQ: Cookies and some other stuff I didn’t catch.

10:02 p.m.: Our Japhet Weeks says that Rodoni HQ has pretty much emptied out. A few diehards waiting for more results, but everyone else pretty much left after Johanna Rodoni gave her thank-you speech and hour ago.

10:04 p.m.: Cigarette break.

10:12 p.m.: Third report, not posted on the Web site yet:

FIRST DISTRICT:
12 out of 23 reporting

Vevoda: 28.34 percent
Smith: 71.56 percent

SECOND DISTRICT
0 out of 27

Clendenen: 36.4 percent
Rodoni: 39.25 percent
Fennell: 24.17 percent

THIRD DISTRICT
4 out of 28

Plumley : 40.81 percent
Pitino: 10.75 percent
Lovelace: 48.19 percent

10:14 p.m.: Lovelace coming up very quickly with only four precincts counting. Rodoni languishing.

10:16 p.m.: Rodoni languishing … because no more votes have been counted in the Second.

10:22 p.m.: “I’m a little nervous,” Clif Clendenen tell Heidi Walters. “Win lose or draw, I think it’s been a positive experience. I’ve pulled a lot of people into the process, both in the southern and northern parts of the district.” They’re in the dark at Clendenen HQ — no wi-fi. So there’s a lot less standing around the computer and a lot more chatting. “All the time I’ve lived in Southern Humboldt we’ve been hoping for a moderate,” says Anna Hamilton, who actually now lives just over the line in Mendo County. “I’m opposed to Estelle,” Hamilton continues. “I was a former member of the Mateel board.” Proving, again, that the wounds from the great SoHum Reggae War are deep indeed.

10:31 p.m.: Crack reporter Bob Doran files his first report of the night. At Mark Lovelace’s party, he says: Jim Test, Mike Wilson, Bonnie Neely and Connie Stewart.

10:33 p.m.: Confidential to KHUM — gusto, gravitas and a perky bell.

10:34 p.m.: Meghannraye Sutton reports that the reason there’s been nothing from Fortuna yet is that they gather all the polling machines at a central location down there, and all the machines have to be at the location before they’re driven to Elections. When they come in, they’ll all come in at once.

10:50 p.m.: Fourth Report…

FIRST DISTRICT
19 out of 23 precincts reporting

Vevoda — 28.34
Smith — 71.54

SECOND DISTRICT
1 out of 27 reporting

Clendenen — 36.43
Rodoni — 39.28
Fennell — 24.11

THIRD DISTRICT
6 out of 28 reporting

Plumley — 40.43
Pitino — 10.15
Lovelace — 49.13

11:10 p.m.: Word at the Rodoni party is that the police van that’s supposed to ferry the Fortuna ballots up to elections is still parked at the FPD, reports Japhet Weeks.

11:20 p.m.: Estelle Fennell tells Japhet Weeks that the police van bringing ballots up from Garberville just now left.

11:57 p.m.: The numbers aren’t up yet, but Lovelace has pulled above 50 percent in the Third District, and Plumley has fallen to 36 percent. Clendenen and Rodoni are running neck and neck, with the Fortuna votes still out.

12:59 p.m.: And it’s over. After the paper went to press, of course.

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FIRST DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 23
Precincts Reporting 23 100.0 %
Total Votes 5148

JOHN M. VEVODA 1451 28.19%
JIMMY SMITH 3691 71.70%
Write-in Votes 6 0.12%

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SECOND DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 27
Precincts Reporting 27 100.0 %
Total Votes 6629

CLIF CLENDENEN 2417 36.46%
ROGER RODONI 2433 36.70%
ESTELLE FENNELL 1773 26.75%
Write-in Votes 6 0.09%

BOARD OF SUPERVISORS THIRD DISTRICT
Total
Number of Precincts 28
Precincts Reporting 28 100.0 %
Total Votes 4662

BRYAN PLUMLEY 1600 34.32%
PAUL PITINO 595 12.76%
MARK LOVELACE 2454 52.64%
Write-in Votes 13 0.28%

1:00 a.m.: Result: There will be a runoff between Clif Clendenen and Estelle Fennell in the fall — unless the Rodoni supporters come up with some sort of grounds for a legal challenge. Barring an uncounted-absentee miracle, Mark Lovelace is the new Third District Supervisor.

1:03 a.m.: Good night, and thanks for playing along at home!

Join the Conversation

46 Comments

  1. Hank

    Don’t see a link to today’s election results on the County site. Am I missing it?

  2. What no First?

    Number of Precincts 23

    Total Votes 2471
    JOHN M. VEVODA 623 25.21%
    JIMMY SMITH 1846 74.71%

    OK, I’m off to meet the candies…

  3. whoops now I see it…

    no, I’m not already drunk…

    what the smiley fo sheepish grin?

    😕

  4. Hank,

    Wow…2nd doesn’t look good for Rodoni. I still think Lovelace will pull it out in the third. Jake Pickering vs. Rupp may be closer than Smith vs. Vevoda…Hard to imagine.

    I’m still rooting for Pickering to beat out a Service.

    Bob: Missed you and Amy Saturday night.

  5. Ahhh

    Thanks Hank. It wasn’t there earlier so I wondered if they would put it up tonight.

    But, I’ll stick with you…you’re my hero. Twice.

  6. Say wha???…Did Rodoni and Smith say the exact same thing? Or did you get your quotes all mixed up?

    9:00 p.m. “It’s been a difficult campaign for all of us,” Johanna Rodoni tells a group of about 100 at Hot Brew. “I feel blessed to have you all here. However we come out on this, we’re all winners.”

    9:05 p.m.: Supervisor Jimmy Smith is spending the evening at the Elections Office… He tells Meghannraye Sutton that he doesn’t want to jump to any conclusions. “It’s been a difficult campaign for all of us,” he says. “I feel blessed to have you all here. However we come out on this, we’re all winners.”

  7. Hank ~ how late are you going to be blogging tonight? Thanks for doing it!

  8. Looks like you got it under control, Hankster. Any word on what 4 precincts those were in the 3rd?

    As a Lovelace supporter, I was taken aback by the level of support for both Pitino and Plumley in the absentees. Skew conservative, sure, but off both ends?

    A clawbiter indeed.

  9. Oh, AnnaBanana. Please, for Clif’s sake, for Estelle’s, for everyones’ — exercise a little vocal discipline. The election in the 2nd district needs to be about a lot more than picking sides in the freakin’ Reggae feud.

  10. Bonnie dissed Mike on the air. Perhaps we should have sent Larry in with his bell and his gravitas.

  11. Word at the Rodoni party is that the police van that’s supposed to ferry the Fortuna ballots up to elections is still parked at the FPD, reports Japhet Weeks.

    Hmmmn. Just outta curiousity, what’s the setup in Fortuna – same machines as elsewhere? – and why do they need to physically haul them in to report the numbers? Are all the other machines hauled in, say from Whitethorn and Willow Creek, or do those towns phone in results before the final?

    Seems just a little reminiscent of (wasn’t it?) Gary Indiana, where there were some raised eyebrows in the D primary when the mayor held all the ballots to announce them together.

  12. No computers allowed, as per the instructions of the California Secretary of State. Gotta physically bring the things up.

  13. It was a voter confidence deal. They did not trust the phone lines. But you can’t win either way. It’s a conspiracy if you call it in and it’s one if you drive it in.

  14. Small town in a raucous county. Hot election. Dark, rainy summer night. A police van leaves the station with all the town’s votes aboard.

    Did someone say conspiracy?

  15. BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SECOND DISTRICT
    Here comes Estelle!

    Number of Precincts 27
    Precincts Reporting 4 14.8 %
    Total Votes 3784

    CLIF CLENDENEN 1318 34.83%
    ROGER RODONI 1326 35.04%
    ESTELLE FENNELL 1134 29.97%
    Write-in Votes 6 0.16%

  16. FINAL:
    Number of Precincts 27
    Precincts Reporting 27 100.0 %
    Total Votes 6629

    ——————————————–

    CLIF CLENDENEN 2417 36.46%
    ROGER RODONI 2433 36.70%
    ESTELLE FENNELL 1773 26.75%
    Write-in Votes 6 0.09%
    Number of Precincts 27
    Precincts Reporting 27 100.0 %
    Total Votes 6629

    —————-

    CLIF CLENDENEN 2417 36.46%
    ROGER RODONI 2433 36.70%
    ESTELLE FENNELL 1773 26.75%
    Write-in Votes 6 0.09%

  17. I do not think theese eese the live blogging when it is one hour since the last one, no?

    anyway, here’s the FINAL:

    BOARD OF SUPERVISORS FIRST DISTRICT
    Total
    Number of Precincts 23
    Precincts Reporting 23 100.0 %
    Total Votes 5148
    JOHN M. VEVODA 1451 28.19%
    JIMMY SMITH 3691 71.70%
    Write-in Votes 6 0.12%

    BOARD OF SUPERVISORS SECOND DISTRICT
    Total
    Number of Precincts 27
    Precincts Reporting 27 100.0 %
    Total Votes 6629
    CLIF CLENDENEN 2417 36.46%
    ROGER RODONI 2433 36.70%
    ESTELLE FENNELL 1773 26.75%
    Write-in Votes 6 0.09%

    BOARD OF SUPERVISORS THIRD DISTRICT
    Total
    Number of Precincts 28
    Precincts Reporting 28 100.0 %
    Total Votes 4662
    BRYAN PLUMLEY 1600 34.32%
    PAUL PITINO 595 12.76%
    MARK LOVELACE 2454 52.64%
    Write-in Votes 13 0.28%

  18. Gulo: Had to put the paper to bed. Day job.

    Besides, I beat you and No Ro with the finals and I have the timestamps to prove it.

    Good night, everyone!

  19. hokay, I refresh, and see I am the pwnd.

    (but not half as pwnd as those demanding election of the Vevoda-Rodoni-Plumley triumvirate. World end now, right?)

  20. kudos for hank s, larry t, and mike d for working late night to bring us up to the minute, live coverage of yesterday’s election results. great work guys! thanks.

  21. Thumbs up on the live blogging. Next time it might be better to reverse the updates by putting the most recent on top. That way it’s easier to refresh the page for updates and comments.

  22. I second Heraldo’s praise for your live blogging. This was a first for Humboldt County, right? The local daily doesn’t provide this. I hope you expand this even more for the November election. Should be some dandy races to report on then too.

  23. Thankee, thankee. It was fun.

    The upside-down live blog? Intriguing. Seems like I’ve usually seen it the other way, though.

  24. I’ve seen updates posted on top. When you have multiple updates and a long comment thread the latest stuff ends up in the middle of the page, requiring readers to refresh and then scroll for updates.

  25. I think that bloggers want to read comments in chronological order and are used to the top down order.

    But covering an election live, when the reader wants the most current information first, I believe putting the latest updates on top is a good idea.

  26. The election was a perfect example of people constantly refreshing pages (especially the election results page) to get new info. And as it got late, and the post long, the refresh-scroll routine seemed clunky.

  27. What’s interesting to me is that these candidates were able to raise hundreds of thousands of dollars, while North Coast Earth First! still struggles to survive. Americans still like to put their faith and resources into individuals, namely politicians, and it seems that Humboldt is no different. We almost had financial stability, as many of you know, until we were robbed by the Trees Foundation; I’m sure loyal Journal readers remember that hit piece of an article. Instead of telling the real story, about how North Coast Earth First! was being robbed of $185,000, Heidi Walters and the Journal decided to focus on the divisiveness in the movement and printed just about any trash that people had to say about me. The article was focused on me, so it’s hard for me to be objective about it; most people I talked to were really pissed-off about the article, and felt that it was yellow, tabloid journalism on behalf of the NCJ.
    While the local politicians might need hundreds of thousands of dollars to run big ads and buy lots of yard signs, North Coast Earth First! only needs $5,000 to keep our office running for a full year, with money left over for projects. Does anyone in Humboldt care that people are still risking their lives in the tree-tops, at this very moment, for the forest and the benefit of everyone who enjoys living in Humboldt Co.? We do what we do for free, 100% volunteer, and nobody takes money for themselves, unlike so many “non-profits,” who pay themselves richly for their work. For example, the Trees Foundation people pay themselves at least $14/hr. to sit in their office and skim money off donations to their sponsored groups. We pay ourselves $0. Come on, Humboldt, where’s the love?

  28. P.S. I share the concerns about Estelle Fennel being able to be fair and unbiased. I’ve read that she was doing “news programs” about the whole Reggae fiasco that seemed more like one-sided advertisements for her SoHum friends. I experienced a similar scenario, during the Trees Foundation scandal, when Estelle allowed several people from the Trees Foundation camp go on and on, bashing and slandering me on her radio show, and I wasn’t even told about it nor invited to respond by Estelle. Estelle allowed these slanderous trash-talkers to rattle on for over 15 minutes, uninterrupted, without inviting me to respond.
    When I read the letter in a local newspaper, complaining about how Estelle was appearing biased about the Reggae issue, and how a particular news program of hers sounded more like a paid advertisement for her friends, I realized that this is something that Estelle does, and I lost a lot of respect for her. It’s that small-town clique mentality, and it seems that the level of greed in SoHum has reached an all-time low. When the scandal is on, it’s good to have your friends in high places to help cover it up, isn’t it?

  29. Why oh why does Andrew Bird still live here — and just be cause he’s “him” does not count. Smarmy

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *