In May 1990 I drove Interstate 44 from Albuquerque to Flagstaff with a U-Haul trailing my ’82 silver Civic sedan. The mesa surrounded me on both sides, the highway ran straight ahead to eternity, and out of the radio came voices I couldn’t understand. I drove through Navajo country listening to Navajo radio.
Radio has been my most faithful companion. I listened to The Police and Pat Benatar on WNEW in Yonkers, The Clash and The Knack on WRUC in college. I discovered NPR in D.C. as a congressional intern and continued to listen to it in a small apartment in a section of Manhattan then known as Crack Valley. It kept me company for eight months in Cambria, Ill., population 300, where for a short time I lived by myself and without a television. In the evenings I listened to Fiona Ritchie and Riders in the Sky on public station WSIU.
So it is with tough love that I tell public radio this: Stop acting your age. On Oct. 4, I was one of several hundred people who filled the Arcata Theatre Lounge to listen to Bandemonium, the Humboldt Calypso Band and the Bayou Swamis and celebrate the station’s 50th birthday. On Nov. 6 the celebration will carry over to the Arkley Theater in Eureka for a classical music birthday bash.
Here’s the problem: Public radio followed my long, windy trek from the Atlantic to Pacific Ocean because it is remarkably similar from region to region and hasn’t changed in at least 30 years. I still like listening to it, and I’m almost as old as KHSU.
It is time for all of us in media industries to acknowledge that the world no longer belongs to us but to those who will inherit the problems we fail to solve: Rising temperatures and debt, depletion of fish, overpopulation. Not to mention the disintegration of the news industry.
Young people must wait until 16 to drive, 18 to vote and 21 to drink. We wonder why they don’t consume news media created by people much older for people much older. The repeated message they hear is this: Wait, you aren’t responsible enough yet. But when they look around them, they see a world run by incompetent and corrupt people much older than they.
We’ve so mucked up this world that I’m not sure I trust anyone my age or older to run it. Let’s turn it over already to the people who have the most stake in its future. And let’s start with the news business and public radio.
To do that we have to rip up the programming. I realized this year how old I am because I now like A Prairie Home Companion, when 15 years ago hearing Garrison Keillor’s voice made me turn the dial.
This is the time to reprogram the station. KHSU will soon hire a new general manager. With a new G.M. should come new direction. It should point toward the young. We need to bring young people into KHSU’s Community Advisory Group to design programs. We need to put them behind the mics and in front of the boards. They should pick out the topics for the talk shows and come up with the guests to interview. Let’s open the airwaves to every crazy new thing kids listen to, as long as it provokes thought and helps inform and connect people in our community.
Jettison the folk music specials, the Three Tenors-like concerts and any show that has been reaching the same audience for the past 40 years.
Leonard Downie, Jr., the former editor of the Washington Post, recently wrote a report called “The Reconstruction of American Journalism,” which was published in the Columbia Journalism Review on Oct. 19. In it, he noted, “A growing number of listeners have turned to public radio stations for national and international news provided by National Public Radio. But only a relatively small number of those public radio stations also offer their listeners a significant amount of local news reporting.”
Let’s increase news coverage at KHSU and make that, too, youth-focused. One of the most compelling things I listen to on NPR is Youth Radio — news shows created by teenagers. Young people love radio. KRFH, the Internet radio station run out of the journalism department at HSU, is one of the most popular classes. So many students are so enthusiastic about the station that it seems like a cult. It would be great if the students who prove themselves on that student station could take their shows to KHSU. Pull in enthusiastic students from College of the Redwoods and our high schools. At a minimum, give them the night shift after those of us who listen to Wait, Wait, Don’t Tell Me go to sleep.
Maybe one of the reasons Facebook took off so fast was that we all but shut young people out of every mainstream means of communication — newspapers, magazines, television and radio. The Internet came along and gave them an instant outlet for their pent-up desire to communicate with each other. Baby Boomers were too tuned in to our light rock and oldies stations to notice.
If we let young people take over our airwaves we probably won’t like what we hear. My dad didn’t like what my friends and I listened to when we were teenagers and in college. But he’s long since retired. My peers now run the media world. Tell me, can the millennium generation do worse?
Marcy Burstiner is an assistant professor of journalism at Humboldt State.
This article appears in Studies in Race.

Facebook may not be the best example as the average user age is 33 and their fastest growing demographic is those 35 and older.
Otherwise, I agree with a lot of your suggestions and even advocated for them to a degree back when I was more involved at KHSU (I only did a brief stint at KRFH).
Unfortunately, the need to make money is going to continue to dictate programming at all stations, public (though corporate sponsorships, underwriters and wealthy contribs) or commercial (through, obviously, commercials).
What we do have, and you might have mentioned, is Blue Ox Radio: http://blueoxradio.org/. Check it out!
And that means programming that will sell to that market.
Marcy nailed it!! I have been begging the program director at KHSU to make some programming changes for a really long time …..add new stuff, take away some old stuff and re invent ourselves.!! Full disclosure here..I am one of the relics(my word not hers) Marcy refers to. There are a bunch of us "olders" at the station and I would rather die than for the "olders" to be put to pasture.
Without a doubt there is room for a ton of change and we must have the young ones to continue.
I have , over the years brought young voices to my show and to the station.
Only with the publics desire for change will it happen and even that is no guarantee…
Sista Soul
Marcy nailed it!! I have been begging the program director at KHSU to make some programming changes for a really long time …..add new stuff, take away some old stuff and re invent ourselves.!! Full disclosure here..I am one of the relics (my word not hers) Marcy refers to. There are a bunch of us "olders" at the station and I would rather die than for the "olders" to be put to pasture.
Without a doubt there is room for a ton of change and we must have the young ones to continue.
I have , over the years brought young voices to my show and to the station.
Only with the publics desire for change will it happen and even that is no guarantee…
Sista Soul
NPR budget is a large part from people who donate. Youth, in general, doesn’t donate. If oldsters don’t hear what they want they won’t donate. NPR goes under even more. Bad idea.
More news and local news is fine. Changing the entire format to programming for people who don’t pay for it, is not good. Save that for commercial radio sponsored through ads. Youth do go to malls/internet/store to buy.
Quoting Marcy Burstiner, "With a new G.M. should come new direction. It should point toward the young. We need to bring young people into KHSU’s Community Advisory Group to design programs. We need to put them behind the mics and in front of the boards. They should pick out the topics for the talk shows and come up with the guests to interview. Let’s open the airwaves to every crazy new thing kids listen to, as long as it provokes thought and helps inform and connect people in our community."
An initiative exactly like this is underway in Chicago. It’s an admirable experiment called Vocalo that WBEZ started a couple of years ago. It is also a colossal failure. Ratings show no one is listening and it’s sucking precious unrestricted dollars away from the parent organization, a source of resentment for many donors. You can read more here: http://www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/a-sound-experiment/Content?oid=1109171
Hell, I’ll just be happy if we can finally hear Diane Rehm and Talk Of The Nation and get some decent local news coverage like the Sacto or SF public radio stations do.
If you want to see the model for what KHSU CAN be, just look at Ann Arbor’s WUOM, Michigan Public Radio. It’s a great station and it’s not an economic basket case like KHSU has been for so many years.
Wow – I’m impressed that WRUC was mentioned in this article – America’s 1st college radio station. Radio is the most adaptable medium there is. It’s just too bad that today’s youth has such poor examples from which to draw. But I’m thrilled that college-bound daughter wants to be involved with her college radio station, wherever that is. Makes an old WRUC DJ weepy.
Checked out Ann Arbor’s WUOM. It looks like they have No music at all. Doesn’t sound like Humboldt to me. We do need new ideas and people always and if there is the will, space will open up I’m sure.
"Hell, I’ll just be happy if we can finally hear Diane Rehm and Talk Of The Nation and get some decent local news coverage like the Sacto or SF public radio stations do.
If you want to see the model for what KHSU CAN be, just look at Ann Arbor’s WUOM, Michigan Public Radio. It’s a great station and it’s not an economic basket case like KHSU has been for so many years."
Winslow-
I hate to tell you to listen to another public radio station, but if you want to hear Rehm or Talk of the Nation, they are both already on the air here –
at 7 and 11 a.m. respectively – on JPR’s "News and Information" service, broadcast locally at 91.5 FM.
There are those of us at KHSU who think we’ve got enough outside news and talk on our own airwaves, and to add more of these types of shows takes away from our local diverse programming.
Local news would be a great asset, but it’s very expensive to hire a news department (I’m talking more than one overworked news director).
As for KHSU being an "economic basket case", I’m afraid that is NOT the case. For a small station like ours in a tiny media market, we actually do better, per capita, raising money than our national counterparts.
Certainly, we could always use more money (who couldn’t?), and yes, the funds we receive from the university have been slashed dramatically in recent years.
However, our financial picture is pretty decent these days. The local community has been very generous in supporting KHSU, and credit should be given to our acting GM, Patrick Cleary, our development director, David Reed, and our underwriting coordinator, Jeff DeMark, who are working hard to keep KHSU in the black.
I appreciate the sentiment of the piece. As a Millennial I am frustrated with the lack of presence my generation has in public radio broadcasting. Last year I did a 3 month stint with Generation Public Radio Exchange as a Youth Editorial Board member. I was responsible for writing reviews and providing feedback for youth produced radio pieces. It was a thrill to nourish the next generation of sound all the while being nourished
myself. Some of the pieces I encountered were the most compelling radio pieces I’ve ever heard.
Your column reminded me of a John Updike excerpt (an excerpt so good I ripped it out of The New Yorker in the Mad River Hospital lobby):
"He was young, but it wasn’t his youth that impressed me; it was his uniform,
his badge, his authority. We were all young, relatively, as I look back at us.
It has taken old age to make me realize that the world exists for young
people. Their tastes in food and music and clothing are what the world is
catering to, even while they are imagining themselves victims of the old."
When it comes to my generation, sometimes I side with Updike; we’re IMAGINING ourselves victims of the old. Other times though, I tend to agree more with you; we ARE victims of a lack of opportunity and long-term planning. In the new frontier of media, marginalizing youth is only going to hurt the industry, so why is the industry doing it? It’s counter productive. There’s a hole in the bucket and they drilled it there.
I wanted to ask you about the KHSU Community Advisory Group. Is there such a thing? Can you tell me anything more about it? I would love to be a part of
that and help usher in some young folks.
I agree that local reporting needs to be beefed up at KHSU. That thing they call the community calendar falls much too short. And I get really
frustrated with the HUGE chunks
of classical music at 10 a.m. I don’t understand why they dedicate
that slot for classical music. I appreciate the sounds of Bach, Brahms and Chopin, but two hours five days a week at a key time slot doesn’t help bring in a new set of ears.
The disadvantage of my generation is that our hindsight is extremely
nearsighted. We are so far removed from old time radio that we don’t even know what radio programming is. To me, it’s programs like ‘A Prairie Home Companion.’ I was a bit perturbed when you poo-poo’d it as prune juice. I fear that if public radio stations handed us youth the reins we would just play music. Without guidance it would turn into indie music overload. I feel like we’re dismissing classic formats with proven formulas,like sitcoms and game shows and suspense much too easily here. I think with a tweaked context (the college dorms instead of the wild west) it could have a revival. Talk shows would be a good format for us. The topics are always relevant. A youth based ‘This American Life’ would work well too.