Humboldt residents and water rights activists hold a rally outside the state water board hearing leading up to public comment. Credit: Photo courtesy of Regina Chichizola.

During a recent meeting, the state’s water board granted advocates seeking to protect the health of the Trinity and Klamath rivers a small concession that could lead to, but does not guarantee, stronger legal safeguards in the future.

A contingent from California’s northern reaches, including tribal members and representatives of Communities United for Water Protection, a local nonprofit focused on helping those living near rivers and lakes advocate for themselves on water rights issues, traveled to Sacramento late last month to make their case. 

While the State Water Resources Control Board meeting was centered on the Bay-Delta Plan, which aims to protect water quality and regulate flows to benefit agricultural, recreational and municipal use in the San Francisco Bay and Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta watershed, their focus was on those rivers hundreds of miles away. 

Ones, they say, that are being left behind in the plan that diverts water from the north to meet the Central Valley’s needs. 

Among the contingent’s requests were scheduling a water rights hearing, implementing protections for river flows and changing temperature standards vital to preserving the salmon species woven into local economies and tribal cultural ceremonies. 

With the vague language around Trinity River water use included in the update that sat before the board, local activists worry a lack of specific limitations for the Trinity could exhaust more resources than it has, putting the ecosystem at-risk along with the traditions and way of life of local tribes who have been intricately linked to the rivers and the salmon in its waters since time immemorial.

CUWP Managing Director Regina Chichizola reviews the history of water rights for the Trinity River and how current legislation doesn’t prioritize its health. Credit: Photo by Griffin Mancuso

During the hearing, Hoopa Valley Tribe member Dana Rose Colgrove described how the stretch of river she used to frequent in her youth, once too deep and powerful to swim across, has become a dwindling creek people can now walk over.

“You guys aren’t thinking about the climate change,” she said. “With the climate coming, there’s not going to be a whole bunch more water. We only got 10 drops and we’re fighting over 10 drops. You guys are trying to give a water right away to another project.

“It’s bullshit,” Colgrove continued. “So I’m just kind of disgusted because I had [to] come clear to Sacramento to tell you guys this. I’ve been here before. We fought over the [Klamath] dams for 20 years and we finally got it done. So we’re going to fight over this water … till I die to get it done.”

After marathon — and sometimes contentious — hearings spread over two days, the board voted Oct. 29 to include a local public scoping workshop on Trinity River water quality and flow issues as part of their new Bay-Delta Plan update following  hours of public comments from environmental organizations and tribal representatives.

A section of the Trinity River, which is home to species of salmon that are vital to local tribes. Credit: Photo by Griffin Mancuso

Unlike the water rights hearing the contingent sought — a judicial proceeding where the board accepts evidence and testimony that can result in legal protections —a public scoping workshop allows for community feedback but doesn’t require action from the board. 

After some back and forth among water board members, the update draft was amended to require its staff “conduct a public board scoping workshop to consider minimum instream flow, temperature, and other requirements for the Trinity River to provide for the reasonable protection of fish and wildlife beneficial uses” no later than two years after the update was adopted. The workshop will be scheduled after the federal government completes its annual report on the river, and hosted with input from county, regional, state and other impacted agencies.

Following the hearing, CUWP Policy Analyst Tom Stokely said he believes the board’s proposal is a step forward but lacks substance and accountability.

“We were promised a water right hearing in [1989] that would actually establish enforceable standards on the Trinity River. They’ve never had that hearing, and now all they’ve promised is a staff workshop on the Trinity River. They aren’t even going to convene a water right hearing where they could impose conditions on the Bureau of Reclamation’s water rights that would protect the Trinity fish,” Stokely said. “So, it’s basically something to say, ‘All right, we’ll hear what you have to say, but we don’t have to do anything about it.’ And I don’t believe they intend to do anything about it either.”

More optimistic about the outcome was Trinity County Administrative Officer Trent Tuthill.

Georgiana Gensaw explains the salmon species living in the river and how they need access to cold water during certain times of the year to complete their migratory and spawning cycles. Credit: Photo by Griffin Mancuso

“Following our participation in the board’s hearing, we are encouraged by this commitment and look forward to working collaboratively with tribal governments, neighboring counties, state and federal agencies and other stakeholders,” Tuthill said in a press release. “As the county where the Trinity River originates, we recognize the importance of preserving and protecting this invaluable resource, its beneficial uses and the communities that depend upon it.”

Leading up to the hearing, the CUWP hosted presentations to educate the public on the history of water rights for the Trinity River, why it needs additional protections and how people can advocate for its health.

Spanning 165 miles, the Trinity primarily feeds into the Klamath River closer to the coast. A dam near Weaverville forms Trinity Lake, which is periodically opened to let cold water regulate temperatures downstream and support salmon runs. The state is currently allowed to have up to 51 percent of the Trinity’s flow diverted to the Sacramento Valley, dropping from 80 percent before 2000, CUWP Managing Director Regina Chichizola explained at one of the presentations. 

However, this rule isn’t always followed, Stokely emphasized. Data from the Trinity River Restoration Program shows over double the full natural flows into the river’s reservoir were diverted to the Central Valley in 2020 and 2021.

Since the Trinity feeds into the Klamath, Chichizola noted, the negative impacts on the river’s flows and wildlife health could be widespread without protections. For example, the salmon populations in both rivers require seasonal releases of cold water to survive spawning and migration, which isn’t included in the plan. Chichizola also mentioned the voluntary agreement pathway in the update could give parties receiving water from the Trinity more power over its flow and temperature limits.

“They could have put really strong protections [in the plan’s draft] for the Trinity River, saying, ‘You need this much carryover storage, or you can’t take the water. You need this kind of temperature in the Trinity River, or you can’t take the water.’ But instead, they just put some very vague language saying, ‘We don’t want redirected impacts,’” Chichizola said at the presentation.

The Trinity and Klamath are home to coho and Chinook salmon populations, the former of which is considered threatened for the region. The lower Klamath River, due to its previous four dams preventing adequate water and flow and temperature regulation, lost 34,000 salmon within a week in 2002, leaving devastating economic and cultural impacts on the surrounding tribes.

 Now, Yurok and Karuk tribal member Georgiana Gensaw fears that could happen again through the Bay-Delta Plan update. 

“If the Trinity doesn’t get water, the Klamath doesn’t get water, which means my sons don’t get to go fishing,” Gensaw said, at the same presentation. “And what does that mean? That means a part of our culture, a part of tradition and something they’re made to do will stop. And that would be devastating. That would be catastrophic.”

Back at the meeting, water board Chair Joaquin Esquivel had recommended the update be passed as is, noting the proposed version of the plan requires the board to consult a tribal advisory group, have an engagement plan and only use traditional ecological knowledge after review and consent.

“What that [1995] plan lacked was the structure to make collaboration last. This plan keeps the instinct and supplies the structure. That is the foundation of my support,” Esquivel said. “I’m also struck by where the criticism lands. Some agencies say we kept too much oversight. The coalition [of tribes and environmental agencies] says we kept too little. They are pointing at the same provisions from opposite directions. That does not make the plan perfect. It does tell me the plan sits where a regulator should: accountability for everyone who participates and protection that does not depend on who participates.”

Tribal representatives living near the Klamath and Trinity rivers expressed frustration with the lack of protections for their portion of the watershed.

 Several students from Hoopa Valley High School also spoke remotely to the board about the impact of the low water levels and the inability to regularly release water. One, Chloe Kissner, recalled rampant toxic algae blooms giving people rashes and bumps and ceremonial boats getting stuck in shallow rocks.

“I’m worried for our animals, environment, culture and community. Not to mention, the Hoopa Valley and Yurok reservations have the reserve right to fish in the water of the Trinity and Lower Klamath for ceremonies. We were assured and promised that any projects, operations and diversions were to not harm tribal trust resources and fisheries,” Kissner said. “So, in conclusion, I want our river water to stay consistently a healthy water level. I want to see water let out. I’m tired of seeing my community struggle with these problems with the river.”

Chichizola spoke about how multiple agreements on water rights in Humboldt County have never resulted in specific protections on the state level, even though local organizations have been asking for these protections for the last eight years. The plan, she told the board, lists different temperature standards for the rivers in Sacramento compared to the Trinity, even though water releases are needed for the well-being of salmon.

“This is a life and death matter for folks. We all drove here from five to six hours because people are sick of watching fish kills in the Klamath River. Water was released this year, and it has been released a lot of the years, but some years that water is not cold. And if this plan goes forward and we don’t figure out how to protect the Trinity River, that water might not be there in future years,” Chichizola said. “This is also critical to the whole economy of the North Coast … because we live in a rural area. We don’t have much left for our economies. Salmon fishing is what we have. All of our water, all of our resources, they come down here, but nothing flows back up to us.”

Stokely talked about how the Trinity’s temperature objectives of 56 degrees listed by the water board will have a 100-percent fatality rate for coho salmon and some Chinook salmon. Former state Assemblymember Wesley Chesbro tried to introduce legislation requiring the state board to hold a water rights hearing in 2014, Stokley said, but the board rejected it due to potential costs. However, Gov. Gavin Newsom announced in August that tribal stewardship, salmon recovery and desert protection projects would be allocated $44 million by the state.

“The money is there for the Trinity, but is the commitment?” Stokley asked. “We ask you, as part of the Bay-Delta plan, to commit to a future Trinity River water rights hearing and to obtain funding for it. The hearing could occur in a year or two after the current Trinity [Endangered Species Act] reconsultation is complete. In lieu of state funding, you could also send a bill to [the Bureau of] Reclamation and their contractors per your current fee policies. You are not without options, but you don’t appear to have the will.”

Board members Jared Blumenfeld and Nichole Morgan agreed the Trinity needs enforceable minimum flow and temperature requirements in the plan. Blumenfeld recommended scheduling a workshop allowing local tribal governments and Trinity County officials to coordinate the best approach possible, along with a public scoping meeting and water rights hearing to consider additional protections.

“I appreciate that staff are overextended, and I take those concerns very seriously, but we need to distinguish between the difficulty of doing this work and the importance of doing it,” Blumenfeld said. “I don’t think another request for a work plan or another report in 60 days gets us any closer. If staff can’t undertake this work within the existing resources, then we need to have an honest conversation about what gets deprioritized or what additional resources are required in our upcoming annual board prioritization discussions. This is a management and governance decision for us to make as a board. We can’t allow the Trinity River’s unresolved water rights issues to remain indefinitely on the back burner.”

Vice Chair Dorene D’Adamo and board member Sean Maguire had different perspectives, saying they didn’t feel comfortable making a decision and suggested making the addendum a separate item for a future agenda.

“We have a ton of priorities on the water rights side. If you just think about the Scott and the Shasta and Clear Lake and Mona Lake and some other water bodies … we have a ton going on,” Maguire said. “When you think about our public trust commitments and obligations, I’m incredibly concerned about our resources that we currently have in-house and our ability to take this on and commit to any dates at this time.”

Blumenfeld added additional context to his viewpoint, reminding Maguire the board had planned for a hearing on Trinity-specific protections from 1989 that wasn’t followed through on, leaving the current state of the river an “emergency.”

“It’s very hard to have any legitimacy around an issue as important as the Trinity if we don’t have a date certain on something that we promised to do 37 years ago,” Blumenfeld said. “So, the overpromising and underdelivering is not something that I believe we stand for. And there’s been a significant shift. If there’s a significant shift in just language around tribal beneficial uses, that’s a problem. That’s a problem to me because we’ve already agreed to do this.”

Multiple options for addressing Trinity protections were considered, with some variations only including a workshop, another having a public scoping meeting and one with all Blumenfeld’s suggestions. Morgan attempted to introduce more specific language promising more protections and timely action from the board, but Esquivel voted against it, saying the board already took steps to get input from tribal members.

In the end, a public scoping workshop was added and the revised plan update passed 4-1, with Morgan dissenting.

In the aftermath, Chichizola said a water rights hearing would have guaranteed solid protections for the Trinity compared to a public scoping meeting, which may not result in any action at all. For now, the organization is waiting to see what action, if any, the federal government decides on for the Trinity. 

“If the federal government chooses a really good option in the biological opinion, then that will change the way the state process goes forward … but ultimately, because [the water board members] haven’t taken action in 36 years, the worst option we can get is for the federal government to go back to what the water quality plan is for the Trinity River on the state level.”

At the CUWP presentation before the board’s decision, Gensaw said the fight to protect the Klamath and Trinity will continue past the hearing. She compared it to caring for sick children and having a delicate balance of attention between the two.

“It’s really important that we remind them that the Klamath is only as healthy as its sister Trinity is, and the Trinity is only as healthy as the Sacramento [River] is and the American River,” Gensaw said. “Because it’s all connected, and I know that’s hard for a lot of people to grasp, but it really is. If you look at the water table, where water comes from, it’s all really connected.”

Griffin Mancuso is a California Local News Fellow placed with North Coast Journal, Inc. Reach him at (707) 442-1400, or griffin@northcoastjournal.com. The California Local News Fellowship is a state-funded initiative to support and strengthen local news reporting. Learn more about it at fellowships.journalism.berkeley.edu/cafellows.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *