Sarah Traywick, Julia Steele and Lyn Trischum in NCRT’s "She Loves Me". Credit: Photo by Caroline Needham

Classical musicals are built differently; they predominantly rely on nostalgia, character development and relaxed story maturation, born in a time when people had the attention span to patiently watch a story unfold. The 1964 musical She Loves Me, written in that Golden-Age style, is North Coast Repertory Theater’s newest offering at the 5th and D Street Theatre. Director Andrea Zvaleko capitalizes on fantastic performances, a nonchalant approach and the charm of the work to create a mesmerizing piece.

Amalia Balash (Sammi Pietanza) acquires a job at Maraczek’s Parfumerie and immediately clashes with top employee Georg Nowack (Evan Needham). While animosity grows in the shop, they each cultivate feelings for their respective anonymous pen pals, unaware that they are writing to each other. Fellow coworkers Ilona Ritter (Meaghan Sharrard) and Steven Kodaly (Alex Benn) manage an illicit relationship through the latter’s womanizing while young Arpad Laszlo (Julian Smith) works to advance his position, and Landislav Sipos (Joe Cherry) grounds the shop through Mr. Maraczek’s (Craig Benson) increasingly misappropriated abuse. 

While Zvaleko stays true to the classical style, more attention to dynamics in pacing, bolder choices and stage composition might bring a solid production to the next level; the strong performances maintain the charisma, but at times it feels hypnotic and suppresses the energy needed to sustain engagement for modern audiences. With a story that doesn’t fully blossom until the end of the first act — catalyzed by a show-stopping “romantic atmosphere” ushered in by the incredible Head Waiter (Komboujia) the first half pace can be pressed to bank moments needed for chemistry and tenderness. Pietanza and Sharrard tame their usual Dell’Artian flamboyance with a natural style befitting the production. It highlights their acting dexterity and allows the audience to connect to their experiences in beautiful performances that build trust. Needham always delivers strong and consistent performances. I would love to see him lean into physicality with love intoxicating his movements and adding unpredictability and giddiness to his character. Working on chemistry with Pietanza may also help. Benn replaces Kodaly’s smarminess with bravura. While the choice works to emphasize the character’s confidence, it can disenchant the audience and weaken the connection needed for heightened comedy. Benson gives a masterclass on how dance can naturally exist in characters’ movements and enhance the totality of choices. Cherry is perfect and always in every moment. Smith works hard to play the younger character in a cute performance that excites me for his future roles. Every character is enhanced by an amazing ensemble that adds texture and joy. More attention to the composition of the scenes, particularly with large clumps creating imbalance and inappropriate power dynamics in split levels, could amplify their choices. 

With the obvious attention to story and its delivery, equal attention to the production and tech aspects could enhance an already solid piece. The ambitious and dynamic set design (David Hamilton), while technically impressive with multiple turn tables and unfolding aspects, feels rushed in its finish with unhidden masking tape, gaps in walls and uneven lines. Scenes where telephones and coat racks remain despite a change in scene and colors that scream Christmas despite the more neutral costumes could have been better. The costumes (Megan Hughes) are standard save for a fantastic Amalia dress and lovely ensemble pieces. Equally standard is the lighting (Michael “Spike” Foster), though the choice to block actors at the feet of the first row is always a challenge that he nails. Is there no way to light aisles from behind the audience to avoid the necessity of using a program to block an ellipsoidal to the face? A couple of makeup (Karen Echegary) choices, such as the waiter’s clown face and unblended male blush, are in such deep contrast to the rest of the excellent design that they are odd. Holly Couling’s choreography (full disclosure, this is a position I took on but left early in this show’s development) is great. I might emphasize that choreography is an extension of character movement and suffers when an obvious count and preparation to move feel forced and unnatural. Still, the choreography itself is excellent. The music direction (Elaine Yslas) and live band are a treat. Once the piccolo gets tuned and balanced, the music is transformative. 

I love this show and its performance. It reminds me of a time when the magic of theatre pierces the veil of stressful, mundane life and lulls me into a sense of safety and security. In a time where comfort incites suspicion and anxiety, this show is a necessary reset. I suggest experiencing and normalizing Golden Age storytelling and making the choice to surrender to this production’s charm.

NCRT’s production of She Loves Me runs through Dec. 12, with performances at 8 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays, and 2 p.m. matinees on Sundays. Visit ncrt.net or call (707) 442-6278.

Tiggerbouncer Custodio (he/she/they) is an empowered queer Indigenous Filipino artist whose works have been seen on Humboldt stages and elsewhere.

NOW PLAYING

The Exit Theater hosts its final weekend of Fringe Festival plays this weekend, including All That Glitters on Saturday, Nov. 21 at 4 p.m. For the full schedule, see the Calendar in this week’s Journal, online at northcoastjournal.com and at theexit.org.

COMING SOON

Ferndale Repertory Theatre is letting it go with Disney’s Frozen: The Musical from Nov. 20 through Dec. 20. Visit ferndalerep.org or call (707) 786-5483.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *