In 2025, the Siren’s Song Tavern packed up its memories, a little of its decor and its loyal following and moved just a few blocks south on Second Street. For more than 13 years, the Siren’s Song built a reputation among avid Humboldt County live music enthusiasts for being one of the go-to venues, and one of the few that allowed all ages to attend. It was also a favorite watering hole among the 21-and-over crowd in Eureka’s Old Town. Unfortunately, all good things must come to an end — until they don’t. As a lease was wrapping on the previous location, Quinn Clayton had a chance meeting with the owners of the space just down the street known as Jim Dunn’s. He called Siren’s Song Tavern owner Liza Sibley and urged her to come see the space. After much red tape and plenty of sweat equity, the Siren’s Song was reborn.
Transplants, even those who have called Humboldt home for the last few decades, have mostly known Jim Dunn’s as another shuttered bar. Folks who have been here longer know that Jim Dunn’s has a colorful history, to put it nicely — and a long one at that. Jim Dunn’s was one of the oldest and longest lasting bars on the North Coast. Since opening its doors in 1885, the space has been home to three bars. During those 114 years, it was a 1920s speakeasy with false walls, and at various points in its history, boasted go-go cages, violent fights and a hotel with a brothel upstairs. It was even lovingly dubbed “the worst bar in Eureka.” Still, on its quieter days, it was a favorite local bar where fishermen, loggers and everyone in between could coexist, if only for a few pints.
The story of Jim Dunn’s is quite literally etched into the floorboards. The floor in front of the original portion of the bar is worn down where locals shuffled their feet waiting for the barkeep to take their order. The cash register was installed in 1921, most of the bar railing is original and the in-wall refrigerator units (that will soon have a new life with a different purpose) have been there, well, since the place has had refrigeration. Clayton posits much of the material that built the bar may have come from decommissioned rail cars. Despite its longevity, Jim Dunn’s closed its doors more than 30 years ago (that’s another story) and remained empty until the Siren’s Song finally opened its doors in October of 2025. For those who have loved Siren’s Song’s DIY energy, its focus on community building and no-fuss attitude, the move into Jim Dunn’s felt like a logical next step.

Sibley and Clayton keep all the wheels turning and all the gears lubed. Both are there almost anytime the doors are open. Both worked as employees at the Siren’s Song before the two became business partners and purchased the business. Most of what you see inside the building is original, though Clayton has done most of the necessary renovations himself and even built the stage. Sibley navigates the bookwork side of things, built the website and is the primary contact for bookings. She is the first woman owner of a bar inside Jim Dunn’s. Like many small business owners, “Jack-and-Jill-of-all-trades” is just the tip of the iceberg.
Both owners feel strongly about creating a space that welcomes everyone. Open mic nights invite burgeoning musicians, spoken word poets and anyone else that wants to share their craft to the stage. Siren’s Song has also hosted queer mixers and other social events. They are best known, of course, for hosting bands and musicians from near and far. It’s a staple of the local metal and punk scene, and a popular venue for traveling musicians. Here, credit must be given to the Siren’s Song’s resident “sound guy,” Cheyenne “Cheney” (pronounced “Shiney”) Stillinger, who, through his high quality production, has earned the Siren’s Song a great reputation amongs show-goers and musicians alike. Sibley notes that in terms of musical taste, they “prefer not to be pigeonholed.” Hip hop, rockabilly, jazz and those hard to describe genre benders have all performed at Siren’s Song. It is one of the few all-ages venues (noting that it’s only all ages when a performance is happening).

When live music isn’t pulsing through the historic bar, it offers a friendly, peaceful space for an afternoon drink with friends, or alone. Pups are also welcome to accompany their owners after a long day on the job. There’s plenty of places to settle in the spacious tavern. There’s even a pool table (with free pool on Wednesdays). The bartenders (Clayton and Sibley, of course) serve up a selection of local beverages on tap and work with a full bar. Classic cocktails are always available, as well as tasty rotating specials.
Turning toward the history from the space and not away from it, Sibley hopes to begin recording the stories from the space’s past life as Jim Dunn’s, as many regulars, now getting on in years, are revisiting the space for the first time in decades. We look forward to the lore that is sure to emerge from this new iteration of the Siren’s Song and the next generation of regulars.
Be sure to check out their website and Instagram for information on open mic nights, upcoming shows and hours of operation.

This article appears in My Humboldt Life October 2026.
