Jan. 16, 2003 by GEOFF S. FEIN The well-publicized dispute between the Environmental Protection Information Center and the city of Eureka over a proposed Target store at the north end of town boils down to differing interpretations of the city's General Plan. EPIC says the city is allowing Target to build closer to the Eureka Slough than is allowed by its own guidelines. The city says those same guidelines allow for greater flexibility than EPIC is claiming. EPIC is hoping the California Coastal Commission will consider its challenge to the city's decision. City officials say additional hearings could delay the project for weeks or months. Target is planning to build a 138,700-square-foot store and garden center with 452 parking spaces at 2525 4th Street. Target will demolish the existing 86,253-square-foot Montgomery Wards store. The retailer is hoping to open the store in 2004. It has yet to obtain demolition or building permits. The distance between the bay and the Target property will range from 40 feet to 250 feet with an average of 100 feet. Christine Ambrose, "coastal advocate" for EPIC and author of the appeal, said small business owners in Eureka encouraged her to file the appeal. Some of those owners have expressed anxiety that Target could hurt their businesses. "We are not opposed to Target, but we have enough businesses like Target," Ambrose said. Ambrose said the city was not doing enough to protect the fragile wetlands environment near the property. "Why are [city officials] insisting on building 100 feet from the bay? I haven't heard a good reason why it has to be 100 feet. This is Humboldt Bay. [We] want to make sure it's protected." In her appeal, Ambrose said that "new construction should require improving existing onsite conditions. The Target store is not dependent on coastal resources. The Target store is poorly situated on Humboldt Bay, and should be re-oriented." In addition, Ambrose claimed the city has inadequately addressed storm water runoff. Ambrose cited a section of the city's General Plan as grounds for the appeal to the coastal commission. That section states, "The city shall require establishment of a buffer for permitted development adjacent to all environmentally sensitive areas. The minimum width of the buffer shall be 100 feet..." But a closer read of that section appears to favor the city's position: "...unless the applicant for the development demonstrates on the basis of site specific information, the type and size of the proposed development, and/or proposed mitigation (such as planting of vegetation) that will achieve the purpose(s) of the buffer, that a smaller buffer will protect the resources of the habitat area." The city could also require a buffer of greater than 100-feet, the section adds. City officials said flatly that the appeal has no merit. Environmental planner Lisa Shikany insisted that the City Council unanimously approved the project in accordance with Eureka's coastal permitting process. "The city determined that the project is in compliance with the General Plan," Shikany said. "We disagree that a 100-foot buffer is required on every project." Shikany cited several projects that have less than a 100-foot buffer, including several along Broadway. City Councilman Jeff Leonard met with Ambrose back on Dec. 16, the day before the council approved Target's plan and prior the the filing of the appeal. Leonard felt Ambrose was satisfied with the results of the environmental impact report. He said he was surprised when he learned that EPIC had turned to the coastal commission. Leonard said that as far as he is concerned, the project meets the city's requirements. "It is going to be a step forward in terms of environmental quality for that site," he said. "Currently there are no setbacks. The project will improve that site." (A setback is the distance between the bay and Target's property). When Montgomery Wards built its store in the 1960s, the company paved the area for its parking lot almost up to the shore of the Eureka Slough. The store was built before the California Environmental Quality Act went into effect in 1970, so no environmental impact reports were ever done on the site. Today, a chain-link fence separates the deteriorating property from the slough. Residents and city officials who favor a new store say the derelict Montgomery Wards store is an eyesore. Graffiti decorates the boarded-up building. The site is more appropriate for a run-down industrial area than for the northern gateway to Eureka. Weeds are sprouting up through the asphalt paving. There is nothing to prevent waste and garbage from running off the property and into the slough, and there are no buffers in place. Setbacks are important for wildlife and for keeping garbage out of the bay, Ambrose said. "The city doesn't get it." But the buffers will be strictly for aesthetic purposes, Shikany said. "The buffer is not designed to mitigate water quality," she said. "[Target is] not planning to send anything through the buffer." Target plans to put in a water treatment system to remove upwards of 81 percent of suspendible solid wastes (oil, trash and silt), Shikany said. "We are exceeding what the coastal commission asks," she said. "It will treat double the volume as required by the coastal commission." But in her appeal, Ambrose states that removal of only 80 percent of water pollutants is insufficient, and that "additional measures should be required." Even though EPIC's appeal may raise some valid issues, it is up to the coastal commission's staff to recommend whether the board should accept the appeal. Humboldt County Supervisor John Woolley is the area's representative to the coastal commission. There are 12 voting members from across the state. "Staff has [the appeal]. They will put together an analysis and then we judge it by the virtue of the report," Woolley said. The coastal commission probably won't decide whether to review the project until February or maybe March, if at all, Woolley added. If the commission opts to review the project, hearings would be held in San Diego. Report: PL logging worsens floodingby SETH ZUCKERMAN A new scientific report last week linked Pacific Lumber's logging to increased silt and flooding in North Coast streams, and sparked renewed calls to restrain the company's rate of cutting. The study, commissioned by the North Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board, concluded that current forestry rules will probably not bring streams back to health. The seven authors -- five academics and two private consultants -- were selected from a list approved by Pacific Lumber and its long-time critic, the Humboldt Watershed Council. The panel's unanimous verdict adds weight to its conclusions. "The report confirms that if you have an excessive rate of harvest, it leads to cumulative watershed effects," said Nathan Quarles, acting head of the water board's timber division. The $85,000 report is the latest -- and perhaps most definitive -- salvo in a six-year battle over Pacific Lumber's rate of logging. Since 1997, high water has repeatedly ravaged homes and farms along Freshwater Creek and Elk River. Residents lined up expert testimony to tie the company's logging to these floods. The company denied any blame and insisted that its cutting would improve the situation by funding restoration work to reduce the danger of erosion from old logging roads. The new report derides Pacific Lumber's approach, referring to the "untested promise" of the firm's restoration efforts, and faulting PL for exaggerating the benefits of those projects. Pacific Lumber did not return repeated calls from the Journal by press time, but spokesman Jim Branham told the Los Angeles Times that the report erred in confusing past logging practices with current methods. "The way we harvest trees today is very different than in decades past," he told the Times. The California Department of Forestry -- which has approved PL's accelerated cutting -- also took exception to the report's findings. "We keep being presented with models that tell us the sky is falling," said John Munn, a soil and water scientist for CDF. "We just don't see it." Freshwater Creek resident Alan Cook was incredulous. "Homes that have stood in the floodplain for decades are now getting water inside the house for the first time," he said. "The creek becomes muddy and remains muddy well beyond what anyone recalls." Local activists hailed the report as a vindication of the charges they've leveled against PL's brand of rapid timber harvest. "Pacific Lumber is saying that falling trees doesn't discharge waste into creeks -- and this report says exactly the opposite," said Ken Miller, a board member of the Humboldt Watershed Council. "If the recommendations in this report are followed, we would see a dramatic reduction in logging" in Elk River and Freshwater, Jordan, Bear, and Stitz creeks, he added. Quarles and his colleagues will ask the water board to act on the report at its meeting in Santa Rosa January 23. The board could put new rules in place limiting PL's rate of harvest within one to two months if it chooses to do so, he said. Prompt action, in fact, is one of the report's recommendations. "It is essential that corrective actions be started soon and not postponed awaiting research and monitoring that would take place over a period of years," the authors said. Upcoming meetings of the water board will tell whether the science in the report can stand up to the political storm that is sure to follow. Freelance writer Seth Zuckerman used to live in Petrolia. He is now a resident of the Puget Sound area. Deadly virus cancels bird showby GEOFF S. FEIN Next month's Redwood Acres Fair Show, the largest poultry exhibition in Humboldt County, has been cancelled due to the outbreak in Southern California of Newcastle virus, a fatal disease that has led to the quarantine and destruction of millions of chickens in six California counties. The disease is 100 percent fatal to birds, but does not pose a threat to people. It usually hits commercial chicken and turkey farms the hardest, but this time state agricultural officials are finding more backyard fowl infected with the illness. That could spell trouble for poultry farmers and 4-H projects on the North Coast, where backyard operations predominate. "There is always a concern over a statewide issue like that," said John Falkenstrom, Humboldt County agriculture commissioner. The Redwood Acres event would have showcased 1,400 birds brought in by about 100 exhibitors. The annual show typically raises $2,000. If the disease is not eradicated, this year's poultry exhibit at the Humboldt County Fair in Ferndale -- held in late summer -- could be cancelled as well. "I have a feeling we will have to cancel it," said Harry Majors, president of the Humboldt Poultry Fanciers Association. "We hoped [the disease] would have ended by Jan. 1, but [it] is getting bigger than [state officials] had thought." The state has also put restrictions on the shipment of birds into and out of Humboldt County, he said. Just how many birds in Humboldt County could be affected by the disease is unknown. "There are so many backyard people raising chickens [in Humboldt County]," Majors said. "I don't know how many poultry people there are." Ducks, geese, doves, pigeons, grouse, swans, pheasants, quail, emus and ostriches are also susceptible to the virus, he said. This isn't the first time the Redwood Acres event has been cancelled by Newcastle. Poultry farmer Agnes Wilson, 56, recalled that the 1972 exhibit was cancelled because of a Newcastle outbreak in Southern California. Wilson has been raising poultry for show since she was a child. She has seen chickens die from Newcastle. "It's serious. I don't want it to happen here," she said. Wilson, a "Grand Master" (there have been less than 200 so designated since the 1800s), raises Rhode Island Reds in Blue Lake. She and her daughter have exhibited chickens up and down California. At times, Wilson has had more than 300 chickens, but this year her flock is down to about 75. Birds are often sold for as much as $75 apiece. "[Newcastle virus] can hit people hard who have been raising birds all their lives," Wilson said. Wilson knows a breeder in Southern California who had to kill all of his fowl because of the outbreak. "I feel sorry for [him]," Wilson said. The virus could also have an impact on the price of eggs and other food items as more and more chickens are destroyed, Wilson added. Humboldt County poultry farmers haven't reported any instances of the disease yet. That's because the disease typically requires a warm climate in order to spread. According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the disease can "survive for weeks in a warm and humid environment on birds' feathers, manure and other materials." Nonetheless, Falkenstrom said Humboldt County takes any report of dead chickens seriously. Symptoms of the disease include sneezing, coughing, nasal discharge, diarrhea, listlessness and sudden death. The disease is spread primarily through direct contact between healthy birds and the bodily discharges of infected birds. Poultry can die without any sign of having the disease. But once the disease is found, all of the birds in a commercial or backyard farm must be destroyed and all equipment and material must be thoughly disinfected. "You have to depopulate [the farm], disinfect the area and bring in new healthy birds, and then see if they are disease-free for 30 days," Falkenstrom said. "It's a hellacious, labor-intensive quarantine." State officials are also concerned that soil could be contaminated with Newcastle virus for up to a year, Majors said. Newcastle disease has been traced back to fighting birds brought in from Mexico, Majors added. Amazon parrots smuggled into the United States from Latin America also pose a significant risk of transmitting the virus. There have been no reported cases of the disease north of Santa Barbara County. Information on the deadly disease has been sent out to pet stores and the state's regional veterinarian has been sent down to Southern California to help in the eradication efforts, Falkenstrom said. The California Department of Food and Agriculture had already suspended all poultry exhibits in Southern California and all bird owners are being asked to stop the movement and sales of backyard birds. Los Angeles, San Bernardino, San Diego, Riverside, Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties have all been quarantined by the state. Last month Gov. Gray Davis declared a state of emergency in Southern California in order to control the outbreak of the disease. The last known outbreak of Newcastle occurred in 1971. Almost 12 million birds in Southern California had to be destroyed. It cost taxpayers $56 million to eradicate the disease. Palmquist killed in hit-and-runHistorian, and photo archivist Peter Palmquist, 66, died Monday morning in a Bay Area hospital from injuries received Saturday in a hit-and-run accident in Emeryville, just east of San Francisco. According to investigating officer Jason Bosseti of the Emeryville Police, Palmquist was crossing the street while walking his dog, Max, Saturday evening when he was struck by an unidentified driver. Witnesses on the scene said the vehicle may have been a Ford Taurus or a Mercury Sable, either silver or light blue in color. Born in Oakland and raised in Ferndale, Palmquist was a world renowned authority on 19th-century photography and a collector of photographs and photo memorabilia. He served in the U.S. Army as a photographer and was the official photographer for Humboldt State University for 23 years. On the side he amassed an amazing archive, around a quarter million images by photographers of the Western United States, including 85,000 images by Humboldt County photographers. The vast majority of that collection was purchased by the Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library at Yale University in Connecticut to become part of its Western Americana collection. (See Journal cover story, "A photographer's obsession," Jan. 24, 2002.) Palmquist also compiled extensive notes on the images and was preeminent as a biographer of 19th-century photographers. He published more than 60 books on the subject ranging from his first, Fine California Views: The Photographs of A.W. Ericson, a profile of the Arcata photographer, to his masterwork, Pioneer Photographers of the Far West: A Biographical Dictionary, 1840-1865, the first volume in a colossal biographical dictionary compiled with assistance from Thomas Kailbourn. More recently Palmquist shifted his focus to the Women in Photography International Archive. He and his partner, Pam Mendelsohn, commuted between Palmquist's home in Arcata and her place in Emeryville while working on what he described as an effort "to identify, collect, preserve, and disseminate information about women photographers." -- reported by Bob Doran HSU prepares for cutsFurther hikes in student fees are a likelihood as Humboldt State University prepares for the impact of state budget cuts. Gov. Gray Davis is proposing to cut the budget for the entire California State University system by $326 million, roughly equivalent to three times HSU's annual budget. The budget shortfall, also a major problem last year, has already led to $69 million in cuts and a 10 percent student fee increase. Davis' new budget authorizes the Trustees of the CSU system to increase student fees by another 25 percent, a move they are likely to take. "Unless something changes that will have an impact on them, I don't think [the trustees] are going to be very reluctant to increase fees," said John Travis, HSU's representative to the California Faculty Association. The CFA is concerned that the budget cuts will lead to teacher layoffs, increased class sizes, and over-burdened schools as the children of the Baby Boomers graduate from high school. "To say we're worried is putting it mildly," said Liz Taiz CFA's vice president, speaking from her home campus at CSU Los Angeles. She said they had to avoid the mistakes made in the last round of budget cuts, in the early '90s, which led to layoffs, program cuts, and a 50 percent increase in student fees. She added that the student fee increases may restrict access to higher education. She said that the last fee hike led to more than 20,000 students dropping out because they couldn't afford it. "We've belt tightened before," she said. "But I'm always afraid that the belt is going to slip up around our neck." |