THE NEWS | PUBLISHER | CALENDAR
A whirlwind tour through
Native American lands
Story by KEITH EASTHOUSE
Photos by BOB DORAN
OF NORTHCOAST NATIVE LANDS
(at end of article)
HIGH COUNTRY THAT DIVIDES THE REDWOOD CREEK AND Trinity River
watersheds was mantled with snow from a storm the previous night.
A few clouds still draped the highest peaks, but otherwise the
sky was blue and sparkling. It was no doubt cold out there, but
the chill could not be felt inside the bus that was steadily
climbing a pass in an eastbound lane of Highway 299. The 20-odd
passengers occupying the vehicle -- a luxury coach replete with
a bathroom and kitchen -- were free to relax and enjoy the scenery.
Actually, not so free. Ever
since the bus had left Arcata, two Native American tour guides
had been taking turns talking to their captive audience through
a hand-held microphone. Make that educating. As the administrative
office of the Blue Lake Rancheria came into view, for example,
it was explained that this small, 33-acre reservation had been
"terminated" by the United States back in the 1950s
-- meaning that it had lost its status as a sovereign nation
that enjoyed a special relationship with the federal government
and was largely exempt from state regulation. The same thing
happened to the rancherias of Rohnerville and Table Bluff (both
located south of Eureka), one of the guides, Merv George Jr.,
[photo below left] said. "From the '60s to the '80s, they did
not exist as federally recognized tribes," George added.
Blue Lake and Rohnerville, along
with 15 other terminated tribes in California, were "unterminated"
-- meaning their sovereign status was restored -- in 1983 as
a result of a class-action lawsuit, explained the other tour
guide, Mary Risling. [photo
below right] Table Bluff regained
its status through a separate legal judgment, Risling added.
Today, the Blue Lake Rancheria, located within the traditional
territory of the Wiyot people who lived around Humboldt Bay,
runs a vegetable and flower cultivation business, Risling said,
and is building a casino.
then began to recite a few facts. There are more than 500 federally
recognized Indian tribes in the U.S., she said, 109 of which
are located in California, and eight of which are located in
Humboldt County. The names of the county's largest tribes --
the Hupa, the Karuks and the Yuroks -- were not what they called
themselves. Yurok and Karuk, for example, simply mean "up
river" and "down river." The languages of those
two tribes, Risling said, are "completely different, like
Chinese and English." Nonetheless, she added, members of
the two tribes intermarried and joined in certain ceremonies.
While the passengers on the
bus were left to wonder how that had played out in reality, George
took the microphone and gestured at the snowy scenery outside.
Historically and to this day, he said, "medicine people
seek the high country to obtain power. If you climb one of the
peaks around here," he added, "chances are you'll be
standing on a powerful cultural spot for the tribes." The
most powerful locations, he added, are those that afford a view
of Mount Shasta, which because of its towering profile has tremendous
significance for the Indians.
the bus began dropping down to Willow Creek, there was -- briefly
-- a lull in what was shaping up as a crash course on the past
and present of Humboldt County's three largest Indian tribes:
the Hupa, the Yurok and the Karuk. The tour was arranged by Two
Feathers Native American Family Services, a social services agency
affiliated with the Big Lagoon Rancheria north of Trinidad. The
purpose of the all-day odyssey was to educate the participants
-- mostly non-Indian social service workers -- about Indian culture,
so that they would be better able to serve their Native American
Heading north on Highway 96
after leaving Willow Creek, the bus paralleled the blue-green
Trinity River -- "the blood that flows through our veins,"
as George, a member of the Hupa tribe, described it. George,
evincing that intimate connection to the land that is typical
of many Native Americans, said that fish from the Trinity are
unusually delicious. "I personally refuse to eat fish from
anywhere else. I guess I'm spoiled." Nonetheless, he said
that the river, which bisects the Hoopa reservation, is not what
it used to be -- decades, much of its flow has been diverted
to farmers in the Central Valley. The result has been a drastic
decline in the river's once abundant salmon and steelhead runs.
After years of scientific study,
and much pressure from Indians and environmentalists, Bruce Babbitt,
interior secretary under President Clinton, ordered two years
ago that approximately half of the river's flow be sent down
the Trinity. Such a redirection has been challenged in court
by agriculture and hydropower interests. George told his busmates
-- accurately -- that the Bush administration is so far not actively
pushing Babbitt's initiative.
Risling said that the unnaturally
low flow in the Trinity River has had a disruptive effect on
at least one Hupa ceremony -- the White Deerskin Dance, which
takes place along the river and involves the use of boats. Because
the dance usually occurs in late August or early September when
the river is at its lowest, the Hupa typically contact the U.S.
Bureau of Reclamation a few days in advance to request a release
of water. Last year, which was unusually dry, the bureau did
not release enough water. The result, Risling told her busmates,
was near disaster -- a canoe carrying dance participants hit
bottom and flipped, spilling the occupants into the water.
Luckily no one was injured,
but Risling said that the misadventure was interpreted at the
time as an ominous sign, particularly since one of the purposes
of the White Deerskin Dance is to set the world back in balance.
Sure enough, Risling said, a few days later the horrific events
of Sept. 11 occurred. "That was the first time in my life
that a boat (used in the ceremony) had tipped over," Risling
said. She said a similar incident occurred when the dance was
held in the summer of 1939. That, too, was followed within days
by another major disaster -- the invasion of Poland by Nazi Germany,
which triggered World War II.
Hupa tribe member Merv George Jr., bares
a tattoo of a pileated woodpecker. The bird has spiritual significance
for his people.
The bus passed onto the Hoopa
reservation, established in 1864. Shaped like a giant square,
the 90,000-acre reservation is the largest in California. While
armed conflicts in the mid-1800s between the Hupa Indians and
American soldiers periodically forced the Hupa to leave the valley
and take refuge in the surrounding mountains, the tribe was never
defeated and driven off its homelands as were most other Indian
tribes in California. That outcome, termed "mildly astonishing"
by Edward S. Curtis, the famous photographer of early-20th century
Native Americans, may have had more to do with the area's remoteness
than with anything else. Regardless, it has greatly enhanced
the Hupa's ability to maintain an intact culture.
"A lot of tribes haven't
been able to continue their ceremonies, but that's not the case
here," George said. "Our ceremonies still occur where
they always have, uninterrupted on some sites."
The Hupa are a self-governing
tribe, George continued, meaning that the tribe has its own governmental
infrastructure (there are 40 separate departments). The tribe
took over from the U.S. Bureau of Indian Affairs, which moved
out of the Hoopa Valley in 1988. About 2,600 people live in the
valley, which, at six miles long and one-to-two miles across,
is one of the wider river valleys in the Klamath Mountains.
As the bus passed through, George
pointed out a variety of things: a grocery store; an airport;
a historical village called takimildin, where the tribe has restored
several traditional cedar plank houses and a sweat lodge; a collection
of tribal administrative offices; a scattering of modest-looking
homes built with federal assistance; a cemetery, which George
referred to as the "boneyard"; an attractive three-year-old
medical center; and a small casino called "Lucky Bear."
It looked like a typical Indian
reservation in that it had an air of impoverishment about it.
And indeed, times are not good on the reservation. As the bus
pulled up to a parking area, George recounted the grim statistics:
the unemployment rate stands at 40 percent; 50 percent of the
reservation's population is living at or below the poverty level;
and the seven sawmills that used to support the tribe's timber
industry -- long the mainstay of the economy -- have all been
occupants of the bus pile out into the sunshine, only to be herded
quickly into the tribal courthouse, where Chief Judge Byron Nelson
Jr. [photo at right] explains that the court hears civil cases and that
90 percent of the caseload involves family issues such as custody
disputes and domestic violence. The next stop is the tribal museum,
which is small but nevertheless contains a large number of items
ranging from tools from the early settlers; to ceremonial regalia
such as a headdress sporting the red scalps and black beaks of
pileated woodpeckers; and a striking collection of baskets (the
Hupa, along with the Yuroks and Karuks, are known for their basket-weaving
Back to the bus for a short
hop over to the fire department, where inside a spacious building
lunch is thankfully waiting. After 20 minutes of chatter and
eating, the leader of the Hupa tribe, Clifford Lyle Marshall,
[photo below left] appeared and gave a short talk. He made several
points, but the one that was most striking -- and most pertinent
for his audience -- was that Native Americans take a fundamentally
different approach to settling domestic disputes than do whites.
White society gives top priority to ensuring the safety of the
victim of abuse -- as a result, wives are frequently separated
from husbands through restraining orders; and children are often
taken from their parents.
But severing family ties "is
not an option in tribal court," said Marshall, who used
to be a tribal judge. "It's a peacemaker court where reconciliation
through mediation" is emphasized and where both families
involved are commonly brought before a judge to work out their
problems. "Putting families back together is the focus,"
in the sunshine, Marshall elaborated on why such an approach
is better -- at least for Native Americans. "If you separate
a husband and wife, whatever problems they have -- whether it's
alcohol or drug abuse or whatever -- just get magnified. If you
take a child away from his biological parents and move him around
from foster parent to foster parent, he's going to develop `attachment
deficit syndrome' where he can't develop close personal relations."
Marshall, clad in a black jacket
and sporting dark glasses and a buffalo-head nickel belt buckle,
has a formidable air about him. He gives the impression, as some
Native Americans understandably do, that he carries inside him
deep resentment against white society. When asked about how he
felt about the larger society that he lives in, he said it was
"exasperating at times that it's so difficult to get [whites]
to understand certain things -- like recognizing that there are
540 independent nations inside the United States." He said
that people frequently come onto the Hoopa reservation and behave
as if the tribe has no legal jurisdiction.
"People don't question
it when the U.S. goes to war to protect the rights of indigenous
peoples across the globe," such as "bombing Serbia
to protect the Kosovars or attacking Iraq to protect the Kurds
and the Shiites," Marshall said. "But when it comes
to the fact that there are independent nations within the U.S.,
that's just too difficult to comprehend.
"If there's one thing you
can say about white people, it's that you can't get rid of them,"
Marshall had an undercurrent of anger about him, Bertha Peters
manifested sorrow. [photo
at right] At another stop on the
tour later in the day, Peters, a middle-aged woman with an open,
honest face, and Carole Lewis explained that the oral language
of their tribe, the Yurok, is in danger of disappearing. Only
12 people can still speak it fluently and all of them are over
70 years of age, said Lewis, education director for the tribe.
Lewis has taught herself the language, but "I can only speak
it as well as a 3-year-old."
Lewis is heartened that the
language is being taught to Yurok children, who attend school
on the Hoopa reservation that lies just to the south of the 56,000-acre
Yurok reservation. But she is concerned that much will be lost
when the older people still capable of speaking it pass away.
What is most striking about
Peters -- the other woman -- are three bluish-green stripes on
her chin. She had them tattooed there in the 1980s. Her reason
for doing so was to reaffirm her identify as a Yurok by reconnecting
with an ancient tribal practice: scraping three stripes on a
young woman's chin with a sharp tool. The woman's chin was then
coated in soot, animal fat and pitch and eventually took on the
appearance of three stripes, viewed as beauty marks and a sign
of status. So far, four other women in addition to Peters have
received similar tattoos. She said that when she had it done,
tribal elders wanted to know why. "They were taught not
to do it. It was sad for me because I realized that the old ways
were all gone for my people."
Heading back to Arcata at the
end of the day, the passengers on the bus watched a video on
basket weaving. Much of it was about the materials that are used
-- such as hazel strips and willow sticks -- and how making a
basket requires a high level of dexterity and an ability to intensely
concentrate for several hours at a time. But there was one section
that was disturbing: Many of the women who make the baskets have
fallen sick. The reason, apparently, is that they tend to collect
the plants they need from roadside areas because they are relatively
easy to access. Those same areas, it turns out, are routinely
sprayed with herbicides so that vegetation doesn't interfere
with driver visibility.
Looking out the window at the
fading light, one passenger, at least, reflected on how much
the world has changed from the way it used to be. For thousands
of years, the Yurok and the Hupa lived in what today at least
seems a sort of paradise -- endless tracts of virgin forest,
streams teeming with fish, abundant game, pure water. Life no
doubt was short and hard, and certainly there were conflicts
-- both within and between tribes. But they were free of so many
of the things that plague the current era: degraded environments,
disappearing wildlife, the threat of terrorism and war. What
a life they must have led.
Coast Native Lands
Sources: BIA edition 2000,
California Indian Trust Land
William Bright, 1957. The Karok Lanugage. UCPL 13.,
Llewellyn Loud, Ethnogeography and Archeology of the Wiyot Territory,
1918 UCPA AE 14:3,
T.T. Waterman. 1920. Yurok Geography. University
of California Publication in Archeology and Ethnology. 16:5.
Ruth Bennet, Ethnographer Center for Indian Community Development
THE NEWS | PUBLISHER | CALENDAR
Comments? E-mail the Journal: email@example.com
© Copyright 2002, North Coast Journal,