Pin It

Legal Weapon 

EPIC recruits UC Berkeley professor to wage Richardson Grove battle

In a move characteristic of its legal tenacity, the Environmental Protection Information Center found a key witness who helped persuade a federal judge to temporarily halt Caltrans' plan to widen Highway 101 through Richardson Grove State Park.

The decision by U.S. District Judge William Alsup to issue a preliminary injunction against the project last month hinged primarily on a 16-page analysis done by Joe McBride, a professor of forestry and landscape architecture at the University of California, Berkeley. McBride got involved because Sharon Duggan, an Oakland-based attorney with EPIC, asked him earlier this year to serve as an expert witness.

After methodically measuring trees in the park, McBride concluded that soil disturbance from the construction project would injure the root systems of 108 trees, 37 of which would be greatly harmed or die; that the installation of culverts would damage seven ancient redwoods; and that the removal of 54 trees would diminish the health of the forest.

In his decision favoring EPIC and two other environmental groups, Alsup called McBride's analysis convincing.

"Exposing and cutting the roots of these trees makes them prone to infection and drying out," Alsup wrote, sounding not a little like McBride. "Weakening the roots of redwoods adjacent to the road affects the complex root structure of the entire grove. Caltrans cannot plant new redwoods to provide adequate relief. Some of the trees that are likely to be harmed are more than a thousand years old."

Alsup's ruling means the road widening will not begin next January as Caltrans had hoped. Instead, a hearing on the merits of the case has been scheduled for Dec. 1. In the meantime, the two sides are participating in court-mandated settlement conferences, the most recent of which took place last Friday in San Francisco.

Pin It

Tags: ,

Comments (4)

Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

About The Author

Keith Easthouse

more from the author

  • Sun Block

    Windows at HSU’s newest dorm keep heat out
    • Nov 17, 2011
  • Monster Trucking

    Routes to proposed wind farm won’t whack homes or hotels, Shell says
    • Sep 1, 2011
  • EPIC Changes

    Former climbing instructor takes the reins at environmental group
    • Aug 18, 2011
  • More »

Latest in News

  • Tools in the Toolbox

    Looking for ways to restore and protect the state's beleaguered bull kelp forests and in turn, red abalone stock
    • Apr 15, 2021
  • Deciphering the Gaps

    Health Officer, Latinx providers talk COVID disparities
    • Apr 15, 2021
  • A System in Need of Upcycling

    The California CRV system's problems continue to trickle down to Humboldt
    • Apr 15, 2021
  • More »

Readers also liked…

  • Top 10 Dick Moves of 2020

    • Dec 31, 2020
  • 'A Brady Cop'

    Tensions escalate between Willits police chief and district attorney over hiring of EPD officer
    • Oct 17, 2019


Facebook | Twitter

© 2021 North Coast Journal

Website powered by Foundation