
today
1 p.m. Pet Photos with Santa "Claws" Henderson Center
read >4 p.m. Young Parent Support Group College of the Redwoods Kinship Site
read >4 p.m. Teen Writing Group Ink People Center for the Arts
read >6 p.m. The Tumbleweeds Chapala Cafe
read >6 p.m. Blue Lotus Jazz Libation
read >6 p.m. State of the Watersheds Bayside Grange
read >6:30 p.m. The Transgender Day of Remembrance Humboldt County Courthouse
read >7 p.m. John Ludington + Chris Parreira + Colin Begel (acoustic) Mosgo's
read >7 p.m. Peppino D’Agostino Mateel Community Center
read >7:30 p.m. A Commedia Christmas Carol Carlo Theater (Dell'Arte)
read >8 p.m. Humboldt Folkdancers Arcata Presbyterian Church
read >8 p.m. John Ludington + Scott Garriot + Chris Parreira (acoustic) Mosgo's
read >8 p.m. Stones in His Pockets Arcata Playhouse
read >8 p.m. A Christmas Carol North Coast Repertory Theater
read >8 p.m. Keller Williams (sound) Humboldt Brews
read >8 p.m. Air Supply ('80s soft rock) Cher-Ae-Heights Casino
read >8 p.m. KJNY 3rd Annual Glow Party Arcata Community Center
read >9 p.m. NightHawk WAVE @ blue lake casino
read >9 p.m. The Melodramatics (ska) Central Station Cocktail Lounge
read >9 p.m. Cadillac Ranch Six Rivers Brewery
read >9 p.m. DJ Touch Pearl Lounge
read >9 p.m. Bondage Bash Aunty Mo's Lounge
read >9 p.m. Latin NIght The Red Fox Tavern
read >9:30 p.m. Phil Berkowitz & Dirty Cats (blues) Riverwood Inn
read >9:30 p.m. David Starfire Arcata Theater Lounge
read >10 p.m. Music by DJ Sidelines
read >10 p.m. DJ Ninja Retro Dance Party Aunty Mo's Lounge
read >10 p.m. SexyTime: MiMosa and Sleepyhead Mazzotti's Arcata
read >Photos
The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism
By Naomi Klein. Metropolitan Books.
By Shane C. Brinton
In a 1989 article in The National Interest, the neoconservative political economist Francis Fukuyama declared that humanity was witnessing “the end of history.” With the Cold War winding down and Soviet Communism unraveling, “Western liberal democracy” had won the battle of ideologies, argued Fukuyama. People throughout the world were choosing deregulated free market economies and democratic political systems. Changes in the world were not leading to a “convergence between capitalism and socialism, as earlier predicted, but to an unabashed victory of economic and political liberalism.”
Fukuyama’s argument summarizes perfectly the official historical narrative that so many of us have been taught. In this version of events, unfettered capitalism triumphed because it was the will of the people. Their yearning for democracy was in fact a yearning for the wholesale privatization of government social services. Their desire for freedom from government harassment: a desire for the end to government involvement in the economy. It was a peaceful, popular revolution in favor of deregulation and privatization.
Naomi Klein’s The Shock Doctrine is a direct challenge to that version of events. She argues that “free markets” and free societies do not always go hand-in-hand and that, in fact, the triumph of an increasingly fundamentalist form of capitalism “has consistently been midwifed by the most brutal forms of coercion, inflicted on the collective body politic as well as on countless individual bodies.” She illustrates this point throughout her book with examples of how wars, coups d'etat, terrorist attacks and natural disasters have been used to shock populations into accepting privatization and other economic liberalization measures.
Klein draws a fascinating comparison between these methods of collective softening up and the sadistic experiments conducted in the 1950s by a CIA-funded doctor named Ewen Cameron. His experiments on psychiatric patients involved sensory deprivation, the use of barbiturates, and electroshock, among other things. The goal was to “treat” psychiatric patients by essentially erasing their minds, thereby creating blank slates for the creation of new people. It ended up being quack science -- rather than getting a new start, patients were irreparably damaged.
Like Cameron, laissez-faire economist Milton Friedman was obsessed with the idea of the blank slate. As one of the most influential proponents of "economic shock therapy," Friedman urged policymakers to use major upheavals and disasters in order to push through unpopular free market policies. He finally had the opportunity to see his regressive economic dogma put into practice when General Augusto Pinochet overthrew Chile's government in 1973 and made himself president. Pinochet's army killed and tortured thousands of civilians as a team of Friedmanite economists worked to remake the economy.
The tragic story of Chile is one of many in this book. Klein mixes on-the-ground journalism and extensive research to show how the shock doctrine has been implemented in a number of other countries, including our own. From Tiananmen Square to Boris Yeltsin’s shelling of the Russian White House to the tsunami that hit Sri Lanka in 2004 to the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, to Hurricane Katrina and beyond, Klein shows how upheaval and uncertainty have been exploited to benefit the wealthy and powerful.
Unlike so many other writers of the same genre, Klein’s style is engaging and understandable. She is not a stuffed-shirt academic -- she’s an activist, and it shows in her writing. If this book has a weakness it is, perhaps, Klein’s apparent belief that the “shock doctrine” is something new and that she has cracked the case. While Milton Friedman’s cold, calculating brand of capitalism is especially disgusting, the use of collective trauma for political and economic gains was around long before he was. Klein hasn’t discovered something new so much as she has explained how a very old strategy is manifesting itself in even more atrocious ways. Still, this is an extremely well written, enlightening book, one of the best by a left-wing author in the last decade.



















No comments for this entry
post a comment